There have been a few posts going around lately about the effect new age religions have had on wild sage numbers and that irresponsible consumption of these goods can have a very real impact on the environment. Here are a few easy changes you can make to your own crafting to improve your footprint. This post is long and uses a lot of scientific plant names, so if you want a short and condensed version of this post then check out my tumblr post on the same subject.
Herbs/Woods
Sage- Smoke cleansing has become extremely popular among people with a wide range of beliefs, and has seriously impacted the natural growth of white sage, driving it into near extinction in the wild. If you insist on using sage then you might consider growing your own. Many nurseries offer seedlings only in the spring, but this evergreen can grow all year. Seeds can be purchased easily online, or you can stop by a local community garden center to see if they will give you some for free (many will.) If you have a less than green thumb then you can simply switch sage out for a less destructive herb, like lavender or rosemary.
And, as always, unless you are a Native American or are an active participant in Native American rituals, then these are herb bundles or cleansing sticks, not smudge sticks.
Sandalwood- What differentiates sandalwood from other woods is it’s ability to remain fragrant for years long after being harvested. It has a long and complicated history with many species within the family Santalum that produce “true sandalwood.” Some species are so rare that each individual tree is numbered and tracked by their relative governments in Nepal, Pakistan, and India. S. spicatum, harvested and grown in western Australia, is a good alternative to the endangered S. album and S. ellipticum.
If using true sandalwood doesn’t matter to you then similar woods can be used as substitutes. Camwood and false sandalwood/sandalbox are similar enough to sandalwood in appearance and aroma to be good replacements. Easy replacements for sandalwood are also orris root and thyme. Due to the status of endangerment in various sandalwood species, any sandwalwood you purchase, whether it’s the wood itself of the essential oil, should come with a species name, if not country of origin as well.
Slippery Elm- The bark of this tree has gained popularity for use in digestive teas and in crafting. However, this tree has started to appear on “at-risk” and “special concern” lists for North America due to increased rarity. Instead of buying bark, opt for collected twigs if possible. Or, if you live in the Eastern US and Canada, try locating a few trees you can harvest from yourself (do check local laws about transportation of wood due to endangerment or spreading of wood boring beetles. This is a very serious issue that’s spreading fast across North America so do be careful if transporting wood over long distances.) If you want an easy replacement for your craft, try using cypress or parsley.
Resin
Frankincense- This resin generally comes from four different tree species in the Boswellia family. Due to over-tapping (to collect the sap for resin), deforestation for agriculture, and beetle infestation, Boswellia numbers are slowly dropping. Ten trees from within the Boswellia family are on the Red List of Threatened Species, and it’s important to remember that this resin is used by almost every major faith, including the big three Abrahamic religions. If, like me, your practice and offerings rely on frankincense then the country and species you get yours from is important. B. sacra is currently the least threatened species that still produces quality aromatherapy grade resin, and comes from Oman and Somalia. Any good seller should know exactly where their frankincense is coming from and what quality it is. Instead of frankincense you can also opt for myrrh, whose fragrance is different but their properties are almost the same. Benzoin is another good replacement.
Copal- Real, true copal is the middle stage between sap and highly valued amber from a variety of trees within the legume family. Due to it’s rarity, real copal is expensive and difficult to find. Though there are many varieties of copal trees, copal from Central America comes from trees in the Bursera family, which grow on neotropical land now considered endangered due to agricultural deforestation. While genuine copal is considered a subfossil, new resin from these trees is still sold on the market under the name “copal,” and still puts a strain on the trees as they lose their habitat. Not only that, but copal should look similar to amber, so any copal that doesn’t meet that description can’t be guaranteed to come from a copal producing tree. Price and appearance are usually good indicators of the resin’s authenticity, but I would skip purchasing copal all together. Pine resin makes an easy and cheap replacement.
Dragons Blood- The sources of this resin, trees from the Dracaena family, appears on the Red List of Threatened Species as vulnerable, and the habitat is considered endangered enough that there are current and active conservation efforts in place to keep it safe. D. cinnabari is one of these species, and is often used for dragons blood resin (as it’s other name is the dragons blood tree.) Instead of using resin from D. cinnabari, try using resin from a less risky source tree, like D. draco, whose numbers are abundant and not on protected lands. If you’re unsure or want to skip using dragons blood, try using myrrh: it has a similar appearance and fragrance.
Benzoin/Styrax- Most sources of this resin are totally safe to use. However if you see a resin listed that is collected from the large leaf snowbell in Indiana, or the bigleaf snowbell in Illinois and Ohio then avoid these resins completely: these species are considered endangered or extirpated in those areas. This resin is used in everything from food to plastic, so it’s widely available from non-endangered sources and quite inexpensive.
Instead of burning these resins, you may opt for similar ones from unendangered species, like myrrh or pine resin. Or, if you’re feeling particularly adventurous, you can go out and collect dried sap from wounded trees. This will not produce the buttery aroma of frankincense, the woodiness of dragons blood, or the warmth of copal, but it will make a good substitution in blends and rituals. You can even mix one of the resins listed above with a simple pine resin to stretch out the quantity so you use less and need to purchase it less often. Styrax/Benzoin resin is also a good substitution, as long as the above information is taken into consideration. If you wanted and had the means, you could also use crystallized maple syrup as a resin (shout out to all you kitchen witches.)
For all of the items listed above this information applies to both the herb/resin as well as their respective essential oils. Any respectable seller should have species name listed with the product on their website, and you should be able to choose which species and origin you get yours from. I hope this information was useful, and if you have anything you’d like to see added to this list then please comment and provide a source that I can use for that information. If you find something that says information conflicting what I’ve written here then please also let me know and give a source as well. I’d like to be able to provide useful and correct information so any assistance would be appreciated.
All substitutions were determined by following similar herb/resin properties in Incense, Oils, and Brews by Scott Cunnhingham. If you disagree with the substitutions listed or think of one that’s more appropriate, please comment as well so others can see and use your ideas. Thank you for reading.